close

thatsNotSafe said:
I like bare breasted nipples as a cutoff because it takes the guesswork out of the equation.

So you see nipples, yes or no? 100% would say "Yes" -> Explicit

... which is concise and easy to follow as a guideline.

TheSwordUser said:
My line of thinking generally follows rules estabilished by...

... and a lengthy personal view (and I mean no offense by that) that makes an image severity objective on an individual basis.

Decal said:
... Although I personally feel that it could be more specific for each category, it does a great job in an overall context. I am under the impression that if the topic becomes to greatly argued over based on nuances, we will be without a rule by the end. Any complaints we may have are likely down to small personal preferences based on our cultures and views. The proposed guideline is concise, yet flexible...

I don't think the nipple thing one way or the other is going to crush any ones world. An exposed nipple in one rating or the other is still easy to find. I support thatsNotSafe's proposal only for ease of definition and a clearly defined cutoff. I agree with TheSwordUser that it can be subjective, but that's also why we're in this discussion in the first place.

I think we can all agree that anything more sexual than bare breasts with exposed nipples is explicit and anything less is at most questionable. How does everyone view the nipple question? Again, I view explicit for ease of category. Lets focus and come to a consensus before this just dies out as a topic.